Kim Jong Un, world's most dangerous man?
North Korea: Is Kim Jong Un 'the world's most dangerous man'?
Updated 3:59 PM ET, Wed December 28, 2016
(CNN)North
Korean leader Kim Jong Un heads into 2017 with two things that loom
ominous for the rest of the world -- he's tested a nuclear weapon, and
no one really knows how willing he'd be to use one in anger.
North
Korea conducted two nuclear tests in 2016, one in January and another,
its most powerful ever, in September. Add that to a string of missile
tests, both land- and sea-launched, and the world has plenty of reason
for worry.
"Combining nuclear
warheads with ballistic missile technology in the hands of a volatile
leader like Kim Jong Un is a recipe for disaster," Adm. Harry Harris,
the head of the US military's Pacific Command, said in a December speech.
Bruce
Bennett, senior defense analyst at the Rand Corporation think tank,
went further still, saying Kim "might be considered the world's most
dangerous man."
But just how much of a threat does North Korea pose?
Pyongyang's
September test put North Korea's nuclear program in its strongest
position ever, at least according to the Kim regime, which claimed to
have successfully detonated a nuclear warhead that could be mounted on
ballistic rockets.
North
Korean state media said the test would enable North Korea to produce "a
variety of smaller, lighter and diversified nuclear warheads of higher
strike power." Western experts fear that could expand the range of North
Korea's nuclear weapons, possibly putting Alaska, Hawaii or even the US
mainland in danger.
The
warhead tested in September was estimated to have a 10-kiloton
explosive power, almost twice as large as the one tested in January,
said Kim Nam-wook of South Korea's Meteorological Administration. The
atomic bomb dropped by the US on Hiroshima in 1945 is estimated at 15
kilotons.
Despite Pyongyang's
apparent progress on a warhead, Bennett, the Rand analyst, points out
that North Korea's test of its delivery systems, those missiles and
rockets, weren't promising enough to make it a global threat -- at least
not yet.
"To be such, the North
would need to have developed some form of reliable delivery mechanism
for its nuclear weapons that could reach anywhere in the world. And the
North has not yet done that," Bennett said, pointing out that of the
eight tests of longer range missiles (2,000 miles or more), seven were considered failures, and the other was tested only over a short range.
And
despite testing a submarine-launched missile in August, the North has
only one submarine capable of launching such a missile -- and its range
is short, making it unlikely to get past Western defenses to pose a
threat beyond Asia, added Bennett.
Doubts
about its delivery capabilities notwithstanding, North Korea remains
the only country on Earth to test a nuclear weapon in the 21st century
-- and that offers Kim considerable leverage, analysts say, especially
with his continued ability to tolerate the West's only real weapon short
of military action, economic sanctions.
"The
sanctions would undoubtedly deter North Korea's economy and make the
country further isolated ... but Kim Jong Un and his associates believe
it is still worth it for them to have an advanced nuclear capability,"
said Seung-Kyun Ko, a professor at Hawaii Pacific University and a
former research commissioner in South Korea's Ministry of Foreign
Affairs.
Nuclear weapons are "a tool for giving the oppressed people pride and hope," Ko said.
The
voraciousness of Kim's "nukes at all costs" philosophy was hammered
home just this week when a high-ranking North Korean diplomat who
defected to the South earlier this year said Kim wouldn't back down even if offered huge sums of money by Western powers.
Thae
Yong-ho, formerly No. 2 at the North Korean Embassy in London, said Kim
is "racing ahead with nuclear development after setting up a plan to
develop nuclear weapons at all costs by the end of 2017."
The
suggestion that Kim can't be bought off is echoed by Boris Toucas, a
visiting fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in
Washington.
"Kim Jong Un has made
the development of the nuclear program its main source of legitimacy,
connecting his fate to what he sees as the greatness of his nation, well
before economic progress," Toucas wrote in October, shortly after Pyongyang's second nuclear test of 2016.
Kim -- An unstable madman or a calculating mastermind?
Analysts
agree that Kim is far from the unstable madman many present him to be.
In fact, Ko, the former South Korean Foreign Ministry official, called
the North Korean leader "cautious and calculating."
For instance, Ko said, Kim knows he can use the annual string of US-South Korean military exercises, involving thousands of troops and the latest US weaponry, to his advantage.
"He demands from his people and subordinates complete obedience to his
leadership, because the country is on the verge of imminent invasion
from the US and South Korea," Ko said. "He creates cohesion and unity
among his people in facing the invasion."
While he keeps his people in line with talks of an impending invasion, he keeps his adversaries off balance by talking peace.
"Kim
continues to pursue a peace treaty with United States," explained
Bennett, the RAND expert. "And if he succeeds in getting such a treaty,
it is entirely possible that US forces would be withdrawn from South
Korea within a few years, likely to never return."
In other words, Kim wins if US troops get off his doorstep.
Is Kim smelling blood in a Trump-led U.S.?
Thae, the defected diplomat from the North, said this week that Kim senses weakness in the US and South Korea right now.
"Due
to domestic political procedures, North Korea calculates that South
Korea and the US will not be able to take physical or military actions
to deter North Korea's nuclear development," the defector said at a news
briefing in Seoul.
Those "domestic political procedures" include the impeachment case against South Korea President Park Geun-hye over a corruption scandal and the upcoming inauguration of Donald Trump as US President.
But Trump could be a wild card, perhaps as spontaneous as Kim is calculating.
Take Trump's comments on Taiwan
and the South China Sea, for example. They might be helping mend the
strained but traditional alliance between North Korea and China.
"While
most observers argue that North Korea successfully exploits the
distrust between China and the United States, they often overlook the
fact that distrust between North Korea and China has grown at an even
greater pace over the past few years, with North Korea constantly
embarrassing its neighbor," Toucas, a former official in the French
Foreign Ministry, wrote in October, reiterating that any Western deal
with North Korea would need Beijing on board.
It's the kind of thing that could leave Kim wondering just what he is facing with the incoming leader of the free world.
"I
think Kim Jong Un doesn't know how to size up this person, and vice
versa," said Jasper Kim, a professor at of Ewha Women's University in
Seoul. "It's an interesting tale of two alpha males and how they're
sniffing each other out at this point."
So, what to expect in 2017?
The beginning of the year, at least, could be quiet.
"I
heard from a North Korean official that they do not want to make any
provocative actions until they know what kind of North Korean policies
are in the next administration," said Park Hwee-Rhak, of Kookmin
University in Seoul.
That
means the initiative may be Trump's. He's said he would consider
pulling US troops from South Korea. He's even said he might be willing
to meet the North Korean leader for discussions over a hamburger,
something that would please Kim, who "craves recognition as much as he
does nuclear weapons," according to Toucas.
But Trump has also called Kim "a maniac" who needs to be dealt with harshly -- a course of action Park thinks Trump should take.
"I
think Mr. Trump should play hard ball. I think he should ask for a
review and consideration of the military options, including pre-emptive
strikes," Park said.
But if Kim thinks that's in the works, Ko said the North Korean leader could strike out fiercely.
"He tends to be blunt and a bit extreme in his responses to his perceived threats."
No comments:
Post a Comment