More Food Trouble In China
Reuben Gregg is a member of The Motley Fool Blog Network -- entries represent the personal opinion of the blogger and are not formally edited.
Dead PigsThe supposed count of more than 6,000 dead pigs found floating in the Huangpu river is just a drop in the bucket compared to the total number of pigs in the country. However, that farmers would even consider throwing pig carcasses into a river out of which people drink shows a lack of respect for the environment and others. It also brings back frightening memories of the government's attempt to cover up the swine flu epidemic.
Bloomberg reported that the Chinese government “plans to create a regulator with broader authority to ensure food and drug safety and said the agriculture ministry will oversee the quality of farm products.” These are steps in the right direction and show the potential for progress in this still developing nation. But, these changes don't alter the here and now.
Selling Bad FoodSadly, Bloomberg also cited Chinese news sources reporting that “a court in Zhejiang jailed 46 people for selling diseased pork.” This comes after a scandal in which duck was supposedly treated with hazardous chemicals and mutton grease so it could be sold as more expensive mutton. And the chicken quality issues that took their toll on YUM! Brands' (NYSE: YUM) KFC concept.
With so many disturbing food related problems in recent years, it would be foolish of investors not to watch this issue. Some companies to keep an eye on include:
YUM! Brands (YUM)The company took a big sales hit because of quality concerns at its chicken suppliers. While KFC has felt the brunt of the impact, Pizza Hut has also seen declines. This guilty by association issue will likely be a drag for at least a few more quarters, if not longer.
This is a notable setback in a country that management has targeted as its number one growth market. To make matters worse, YUM has expanded in China via the purchase of Chinese food concepts, which almost certainly sell pork products. If the pig scare intensifies, it could hamper sales at domestic brands, as well.
That said, any pullback in the shares should be seen as a buying opportunity. The company has dealt with quality issues in the past and lived to tell the tale. Time will likely heal this issue, too.
Dunkin' Brands (NASDAQ: DNKN)Although over 80% of the company's top line comes from domestic sales at its Dunkin Donuts and Baskin Robbins brands, the company has targeted international expansion as a key growth driver. With over 6,500 stores already open in Asia, the company is clearly a big player in the region. China's massive population means that notable store count growth in that country is going to be vital.
Interestingly, the company's ice cream concept has a larger store count than its namesake brand. This is problematic in that milk is the key ingredient and exposes Dunkin' to the same types of risks that hit YUM! With a heavy debt load, Dunkin' could find a top line hit hard to deal with.
Note that baby milk was found to be tainted in the country several years ago, with more recent episodes involving regular milk tainted with a cancer causing toxin. Baskin Robbins could have a hard time distancing itself from a milk scare.
McDonald's (NYSE: MCD)McDonald's is another big player in China. While most people know it for its famous golden arches, it is also one of the largest ice cream retailers in the country. In fact, it has a fleet of stand-alone ice cream shops. That means that a milk scare could ensnare it along with Dunkin'.
Of course, McDonald's sells much more than just ice cream. For example, the company's chicken nuggets are a mainstay menu item and it, too, has felt a sales hit from the chicken quality issues facing YUM. Management expects the sales drop to impact at least the first quarter's results.
The company's stores sell such a varied list of items that almost any food scare could have an impact on sales. The same holds true for Burger King Worldwide, which has a relatively small footprint in China that management is looking to expand aggressively.
Open EyesChina isn't as open and well regulated as the United States. While that isn't a reason to avoid companies that have pegged their long-term growth on China's industrialization, it is an issue that should be monitored. With so many food scares, investors shouldn't be prepared for the next one.
end quote from: