TRIGGER HAPPY

03.02.16 9:01 PM ET

Cops Woke Up Naked Woman, Ordered Her to Show Them a Gun, Then Killed Her

Deanne Choate wasn’t touching a gun when police entered her room. In fact, they demanded she find the weapon for them—and shot her anyway.
Deanne Choate was sleeping naked under the covers when a trio of cops flicked on the lights and came barreling into her bedroom with guns drawn, believing she posed a lethal threat.
The police officers from Gardner, Kansas, roused her awake and ordered her to show the gun her boyfriend told them she had fired. When she did that after throwing on a hoodie, police opened fire anyway, putting her to sleep for good.
A year after Choate’s death, officers Robert Huff, Justin Mohney, and Jeff Breneman remain on the force, having dodged criminal charges or censure for killing the 53-year-old woman. But their department was slapped with a wrongful-death lawsuit in federal court this week by Choate’s children. Armed with bodycam footage of the incident, the Choates blame police for being trigger happy when they were supposed to help their mother.
“They say she was pointing a pistol at them,” Choate’s 37-year-old son Michael Weddington told The Daily Beast in an exclusive interview, referring to body camera video footage captured from the tragic night that Choate’s family members reviewed.
And after video footage from a cop’s body camera was finally offered for the family to view, Weddington is certain the cops overreacted and could have spared her life.
“Why did they have to get all commando-style?”
It was around 9:45 p.m. on March 26 last year when police responded to a 911 call by Choate’s boyfriend, Andrew Musto, claiming “she was under the influence of alcohol, may be suicidal and had a gun,” according to the civil lawsuit.
The document suggests cops arrived to neutralize “a disturbance with a gun at the home.”
Earlier in the evening, Choate and Musto were drinking at their favorite bar about a mile away and began fighting.
“They had gotten buzzed and [Musto] probably said something stupid because he’s a cocky dude,” Weddington said. “She pulled his card and left the restaurant.”
Back home, they fought some more until their fireworks escalated to a gunshot.
Neighbor Gary Smethers told The Daily Beast that he remembered the first of many shots from that evening.
“Before the cops showed up we could hear she took a shot outside with that pistol,” Smethers remembered.
Minutes later, he said, cops rolled up without their lights or siren on, choosing to park at the cul-de-sac instead of in front of the home.
Smethers and his wife, Theresa, proceeded to watch television before the staccato sounds of gunfire returned.
Get The Beast In Your Inbox!
By clicking "Subscribe," you agree to have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy